Of Particular Significance

Category: Particle Physics

Ok, today I’ve posted the article you’ve been waiting for: What does the LHC have to say, so far, about supersymmetry? [Here’s an article about supersymmetry and what it predicts, and another about standard ways to look for signs of it at the Large Hadron Collider, under certain assumptions; if you want to review the known particles and forces first, you can read about them here.]

If you’ve been reading the press, you may have seen statements such as “the air is getting thin for supersymmetry” or “we’re painting supersymmetry into a corner”. And recently on Cosmic Variance some broad statements about supersymmetry being in serious trouble were made by experimentalist John Conway (before being somewhat watered down after I raised an objection.)

[Update: in response to a comment posted below, I reread this post, and I see that indeed I did not, in the original version, give enough words attesting to the tremendous progress that has been made.  So let me state clearly: what the LHC and the ATLAS and CMS experiments have achieved, in the supersymmetry-aimed searches made public so far, is fantastic.   They have wiped not only many variants of supersymmetry, but also variants of many other speculative ideas, off the map.   And I don’t mean in any way to downplay this… just to try to put it in proper perspective.  To do so better, I also added a sentence after the list of assumptions below.]

A number of experimentalists seem to have (and, in their public statements, give) the impression that most supersymmetry theorists, faced with an apparent disaster, are rushing around in circles desperately trying to think of new ways that supersymmetry might have escaped notice. This view also seems to be showing up on various blogs. This is a profound misconception, one that history clearly contradicts. Rather than a picture of universally panicked theorists trying to figure out how to save their favorite theory, the image should be of a number of theorists sitting calmly in their chairs, saying, “we knew this situation was a reasonable possibility — and we’ve been trying to alert you to it for a very long time.” The statements have been in the scientific literature for years.

Many theorists, including myself [and let me emphasize that I am not a huge proponent of supersymmetry, though I have worked on it and do view it as a serious contender as a theory of nature] have been saying for years that the main search strategies planned at the LHC would be insufficient to cover large regions of the supersymmetric continent. Important papers on this subject go back into the 1990s and a good chunk of the last decade. Here is the point. The bulk of the search strategy used at the LHC to find supersymmetry rests upon three assumptions.

  1. in any process, the number of superpartners can only change by an even number;
  2. the lightest superpartner [which is stable, by assumption 1]  is a superpartner of a particle we know (and therefore, to avoid conflict with other data, an undetectable neutralino or sneutrino);
  3. the superpartners that are affected by the strong nuclear force are significantly heavier than the other superpartners of known particles.

These assumptions are not unreasonable, and there are strong arguments in their favor, especially for assumption 1 and to a degree assumption 3 (described here).  But we must keep in mind that if we relax any one of those assumptions,  the limits on supersymmetry from current LHC data become much weaker. If you want to read more details about how this works, you can click here, though you will find it useful to read today’s article first unless you already know a lot about the subject.  Or click on the figure below (taken from this post, which also explains why these assumptions are often made) to understand how these assumptions lead to the prediction of “jets and missing energy” on which the most powerful search strategies — including the ones we’ll hear about at this week’s conference in Mumbai — are all based.

The logical chain that leads particle physicists to look for supersymmetry in the standard way. SP and LSP stand for "superpartner'' and "lightest superpartner".

So until you hear a consensus building, you should be cautious in making too much of statements that supersymmetry, as a part of nature and a solution to the hierarchy problem, is in serious trouble.  The truth is that certain variants of supersymmetry — ones based on certain assumptions that might be wrong — are indeed strongly constrained by current data.  Others, simply put, are not.  In short, we have a long way to go.

8/19/11

Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON August 19, 2011

As someone who has spent several years thinking hard about how to detect “hidden particles” — ones that are not affected by the three forces of the Standard Model, the electromagnetic force and the strong and weak nuclear forces — I am pleased to see the result that just appeared from the APEX experiment, at the Jefferson Laboratory in the US state of Virginia:

http://arxiv.org/PS_cache/arxiv/pdf/1108/1108.2750v1.pdf.

Quoting from [and modifying for non-experts, in italics] the abstract:

  • We present a search at Jefferson Laboratory for new particles, lighter than protons, that are carriers of a new force and that can decay  to electron-positron pairs [recall positron = anti-electron]. Such a particle can be produced by slamming an electron beam into ordinary matter...  Using APEX data, we searched … and found no evidence of such a particle in a certain range of masses and force strengths.  Our findings demonstrate that experiments of this type can explore a new, wide, and important range of masses and strengths for sub-proton-mass forces.

What they’re doing is looking for a particle that is similar to a Z particle, one of the carriers of the weak nuclear force, but that on the one hand (a) exerts a smaller force on ordinary matter than does the weak nuclear force, and on the other hand (b) is lighter in mass than the Z, so the force it exerts dies off more slowly with distance than does the weak nuclear force.   If such a particle were found, it would represent the first new force of nature discovered in many decades!

A competitor experiment from Mainz (called MAMI) reported results a few months ago.  The two experiments are sensitive to a comparable force strength and to slightly different mass ranges.  You can see their results in the figure, which shows the APEX search region in blue and the MAMI search region in green, and other experiments in variants of grey.  These two experiments are probing weaker forces — looking for force carrier particles that are more hidden — than has ever been possible before.

Both of these experiments are still in the very early days; their results come from short, preliminary runs of data-taking.  They both plan to have a much longer run, which should allow them much greater sensitivity to weaker forces and to force carriers of a wider range of masses.  In particular, the unshaded region in the figure, which hasn’t been searched yet, should be entirely covered soon.

I am also pleased because among the leaders on the APEX experiment are three young theorists, Rouven Essig, (a former Rutgers student of my colleague Scott Thomas, and now a Stonybrook faculty member), Natalia Toro and Philip Schuster (two of my  co-authors on a recent paper, and faculty members at the Perimeter Institute), and an experimentalist and professor at nearby New York University, the ubiquitous Kyle Cranmer (who also is on ATLAS and presented that experiment’s result on the search for the Higgs particle a few weeks ago.)

Congratulations, APEX!!!

Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON August 18, 2011

Here’s an article intended to give a layperson a sense for why so many types of particles — most of them, in fact — decay away almost instantly, forcing us to discover them through various types of trickery.   This is relevant in the search for the Higgs particle, which decays away far too quickly to observe directly. (See the Higgs FAQ, the video clips from my recent public talk, or the article about recent hints of the Higgs for more info.)

Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON August 4, 2011

Ok, the third video clip from my talk at the Secret Science club from March 2011 is now uploaded for your enjoyment.  [But watch the other two clips first, it will make it a lot easier to follow!]  Learn how to find the Higgs particle!  (Or at least the easier ways — an explanation of the harder techniques, some of which are important in the current hints of a Higgs signal, and further details on the easier techniques, will be posted very soon.)

Attentive viewers will notice that in one of my plots of simulated data the Higgs particle has a mass between 140 and 150 GeV.  I promise you 🙂 I had no advanced warning of this month’s hints!!  […which happen currently to favor this regime…]

Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON July 29, 2011

On the plane back to the US, I put together a couple of answers to very basic questions about particle physics that I often get from friends and acquaintances who know little or nothing about the subject.  I hope you find them interesting!

Note also: my previous post repeated a misquote of the CERN director general (thank you readers.)  This is now corrected  — though the post’s main content is not changed, just clarified a bit.

Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON July 27, 2011

I posted on Friday that the CDF experiment at the Tevatron claims to have observed a long-sought rare process — the decay of a particle called the B_s meson to a muon and anti-muon — and the observed rate is at least 1.5 times and perhaps as much as 6 times what was expected in the Standard Model.  After some careful reading, I have updated my post, laying out some reasons for some caution in interpreting the result.  I still don’t have the full story, so there will probably be another update.  (7/16/11)  

Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON July 17, 2011

The CDF experiment at the Tevatron claims to have observed a long-sought rare process — the decay of a particle called the B_s meson to a muon and anti-muon — and the observed rate is at least 1.5 times and perhaps as much as 6 times what was expected in the Standard Model.  Very interesting, but very early days yet.  I have a preliminary post here — to be updated when I fully understand the result.

Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON July 14, 2011

Search

Buy The Book

Reading My Book?

Got a question? Ask it here.

Media Inquiries

For media inquiries, click here.