The Challenges of Writing a “Colloquium”

Time for a little insight into what it means to be a professor…

One of the most interesting and challenging tasks that academics, especially academic scientists, are invited to do as part of their careers is to talk about their work, and more generally their field, to an audience consisting of an entire academic department.   This kind of talk is called a “colloquium”, and most departments hold a colloquium weekly.  In a few days I’ll have the honor of giving one.

Several years ago I wrote a colloquium on the Large Hadron Collider, which I presented numerous times between 2007 and 2010.  But now, with the huge amount of LHC data that has flooded in this year, I have to write a substantially new one.

It is one thing to give a talk to a small group of experts within a department, where as a speaker one need not provide too much background material, since those attending the talk are already generally familiar with the issues. The same is true for a larger audience at specialized conferences, such as the ones I attended and described this summer.  In such cases, one can focus on technicalities for more than half the talk.  But when talking to an entire physics department?  Even an audience full of physicists can be remarkably diverse. Typically there will be junior and senior undergraduates who are just starting to learn some advanced concepts in physics.  And at the other end of the spectrum, there will be famous established scientists from very different subfields from mine, such as experimental quantum optics, observational astronomy, theoretical biophysics, etc., who may barely know the basics of my topic.  I will have less than an hour to bring this wide audience up to speed on the subject of particle physics, explain the important puzzles that the Large Hadron Collider is designed to explore, describe how the LHC works and how physics is done there,  characterize the most important results from the 2011 data, and examine their implications.  All this while being clear and occasionally entertaining.

Building this website sometimes feels daunting, but the many topics of importance in particle physics can be covered over many webpages, and a reader can study and review the pages at leisure.  With a colloquium, the conditions are much less forgiving; the talk has to be perfectly designed, be carefully rehearsed, and proceed like clockwork.  It’s performance art, and it requires acting skill, people instincts, empathy, and a sense of timing — along with, of course, good science.

27 responses to “The Challenges of Writing a “Colloquium”

  1. What ever you do, please don’t start with a detailed summary of “what this talk will cover”.

    I can’t think of anything more pointless and off-putting. Indeed, for the audience it’s an invitation to get up and leave if the programme doesn’t suit them!

    A great film, play or book doesn’t begin with a plot synopsis, and a great talk shouldn’t either.

      • In a sense I do: I find it usually pays to give people quickly at least an idea of what you are going to do, or something they can hold on to during the rest of the talk.

        Excessive details / common platitudes are not necessary though.

      • I always decide based on audience. If I want money, I won’t tell a suspense story, I’ll respect the giver by respecting their time and patience. If I’m entertaining or educating someone, suspense can be captivating, if done well, and captivation is the holy grail for educators and entertainers. (I’m not sure that I do it well, though.)

      • once upon a time in space,,without a plot time fills the blanks…i cant think of any topic/subject that i wouldn’t want to learn more about…so there is no fear of me leaving,,,there is nothing wrong with listing content,,but breif is always good,wet their appetites,but allow the audience to navigate their own way throuh.however there are many variables to consider,,afterall the speaker in this case is informing/educating not just entertaining,,,

  2. I`m jaleous of the people who will sit in the kolloquim; I`d like to see the talk to 😉 …

  3. a_bad_physics_student

    Any suggestion on how to keep talking speed down when having a physics colloquium, i think thats the hardest thing to do of all?

  4. Pingback: Meanwhile, On the Other Side of the Planet | Of Particular Significance

  5. Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed!
    Very useful info specifically the last part 🙂 I care for such info much.

    I was looking for this certain info for a very long time.

    Thank you and good luck.

  6. real chanel handbags
    I enjoy what you guys are up too. This type of clever work and exposure!
    Keep up the awesome works guys I’ve you guys to blogroll.

  7. magnificent ρoints altogether, you simply gainesd ɑ
    new reader. What migɦt you recommend about ʏour post that
    ƴоu just mase sօme days ago? Аny positive?

  8. Your in a row then ideas enormously handy in my opinion.
    Thanks actual a good deal ahead of time. Your own understanding on this subject matter is
    great, I’m glad that here’s uncover. Many thanks yet

  9. Fastidious answer back in return of this question with solid arguments and describing
    the whole thing on the topic of that.

  10. Je pense que ј’en parlerai ѕur mon blog

  11. hey there and thank you for your information – I’ve definitely picked up anything new
    from right here. I did however expertise a few technical
    issues using tthis site, since I experienced
    to reload the web site many times pregious to I could get it to
    load properly. I had been wondering if your web hosting is OK?
    Not that I’m complaining, but slow loading instances times will very frequently affectt
    yopur placement in google and could damage your quality score if advertising and marketing with Adwords.
    Well I’m aadding this RSS to my e-mail annd can look out forr much more of your rrespective fascinating content.
    Make sure you update this again soon.

  12. Je terminerai de lire ça plus tard

  13. Jе suiѕ entièrement en équation avec toi

  14. J’écris ce com uniqquement poսr féliciter son auteur

  15. Оn remarque de suite que vous maîtrisez très ƅien ce ѕujet

  16. Vous éсrivez sans cesse des posts intéгessants

  17. Humm êteѕ vous sûr de ce que vous dites ??

  18. Un post ѵraiment plein de joliѕ ϲonseils

  19. Encorе un post sincèrement séduisant

  20. Il me tarde de lire votre ƿrߋchain poste

  21. Je suis entièrement en accord avec νous

  22. Moon petit ԁoigt me dit que ce postre va atterrir sur un site internet

  23. Je peux dire qսe c’est véritablement uun ƅonheur de vouѕ