Of Particular Significance

Tag: LHC

A pause from my quantum series to announce a new interview on YouTube, this one on the Blackbird Physics channel, hosted by UMichigan graduate student and experimental particle physicist Ibrahim Chahrour. Unlike my recent interview with Alan Alda, which is for a general audience, this one is geared toward physics undergraduate students and graduate students. A lot of the topics are related to my book, but at a somewhat more advanced level. If you’ve had a first-year university physics class, or have done a lot of reading about the subject, give it a shot! Ibrahim asked great questions, and you may find many of the answers intriguing.

Here’s the list of the topics we covered, with timestamps.

  • 00:00 Intro
  • 00:40 Why did you write “Waves in an Impossible Sea”?
  • 03:50 What is mass?
  • 09:03 What is Relativistic Mass? Is it a useful concept?
  • 17:50 Why Quantum Field Theory (QFT) is necessary
  • 23:50 Electromagnetic Field, Photons, and Quantum Electrodynamics (QED)
  • 36:17 Particles are ripples in their Fields
  • 38:47 Fields with zero-mass particles vs. ones whose particles have mass?
  • 46:49 The Standard Model of Particle Physics
  • 52:08 What was the motivation/history behind the Higgs field?
  • 1:02:05 How the Higgs field works
  • 1:05:33 The Higgs field’s “Vacuum Expectation Value”
  • 1:12:02 The hierarchy problem
  • 1:24:18 The current goals of the Large Hadron Collider

Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON March 17, 2025

Last week, when I wasn’t watching democracy bleed, I was participating in an international virtual workshop, attended by experts from many countries. This meeting of particle experimenters and particle theorists focused on the hypothetical possibility known as “hidden valleys” or “dark sectors”. (As shorthand I’ll refer to them as “HV/DS”). The idea of an HV/DS is that the known elementary particles and forces, which collectively form the Standard Model of particle physics, might be supplemented by additional undiscovered particles that don’t interact with the known forces (other than gravity), but have forces of their own. All sorts of interesting and subtle phenomena, such as this one or this one or this one, might arise if an HV/DS exists in nature.

Of course, according to certain self-appointed guardians of truth, the Standard Model is clearly all there is to be found at the Large Hadron Collider [LHC], all activities at CERN are now just a waste of money, and there’s no point in reading this blog post. Well, I freely admit that it is possible that these individuals have a direct line to God, and are privy to cosmic knowledge that I don’t have. But as far as I know, physics is still an experimental science; our world may be going backwards in many other ways, but I don’t think we should return to Medieval modes of thought, where the opinion of a theorist such as Aristotle was often far more important than actually checking whether that opinion was correct.

According to the methods of modern science, the views of any particular scientist, no matter how vocal, have little value. It doesn’t matter how smart they are; even Nobel Prize-winning theorists have often been wrong. For instance, Murray Gell-Mann said for years that quarks were just a mathematical organizing principle, not actual particles; Martinus Veltman insisted there would be no Higgs boson; Frank Wilczek was confident that supersymmetry would be found at the LHC; and we needn’t rehash all the things that Newton and Einstein were wrong about. In general, theorists who make confident proclamations about nature have a terrible track record, and only get it right very rarely.

The central question for modern science is not about theorists at all. It is this: “What do we know from experiments?”

And when it comes to the possibility of an HV/DS, the answer is “not much… not yet anyway.”

The good news is that we do not need to build another multibillion dollar experimental facility to search for this kind of physics. The existing LHC will do just fine for now; all we need to do is take full advantage of its data. But experimenters and theorists working together must develop the right strategies to search for the relevant clues in the LHC’s vast data sets. That requires completely understanding how an HV/DS might manifest itself, a matter which is far from simple.

Last week’s workshop covered many topics related to these issues. Today I’ll just discuss one: an example of a powerful, novel search strategy used by the ATLAS experiment. (It’s over a year old, but it appeared as my book was coming out, and I was too busy to cover it then.) I’ll explain why it is a good way to look for strong forces in a hidden valley/dark sector, and why it covers ground that, in the long history of particle physics, has never previously been explored.

(more…)
Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON January 29, 2025

On my recent trip to CERN, the lab that hosts the Large Hadron Collider, I had the opportunity to stop by the CERN control centre [CCC]. There the various particle accelerator operations are managed by accelerator experts, who make use of a host of consoles showing all sorts of data. I’d not been to the CCC in person — theoretical physicists congregate a few kilometers away on another part of CERN’s campus — although back in the LHC’s very early days, when things ran less smoothly, I used to watch some of the CCC’s monitoring screens to see how the accelerator was performing.

The atmosphere in the control room was relatively quiet, as the proton-proton collisions for the year 2024 had just come to an end the previous day. Unlike 2023, this has been a very good year. There’s a screen devoted to counting the number of collisions during the year, and things went so well in 2024 it had to be extended, for the first time, by a “1” printed on paper.

The indication “123/fb” means “123-collisions-per-femtobarn”, while one-collision-per-femtobarn corresponds to about 1014 = 100,000,000,000,000 proton-proton collisions. In other words, the year saw more than 12 million billion proton-proton collisions at each of the two large-scale experiments, ATLAS and CMS. That’s about double the best previous year, 2018.

Yes, that’s a line of bottles that you can see on the back wall in the first photo. Major events in the accelerator are often celebrated with champagne, and one of the bottles from each event is saved for posterity. Here’s one from a few weeks ago that marked the achievement of 100-collisions-per-femtobarn.

With another one and a half seasons to go in Run 3 of the LHC, running at 13.6 TeV of energy per collision (higher than the 13 TeV per collision in Run 2 from 2015 to 2018, and the 7 and 8 TeV per collision in Run 1 from 2010 to 2012), the LHC accelerator folks continue to push the envelope. Much more lies ahead in 2029 with Run 4, when the collision rate will increase by another big step.

Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON October 30, 2024

Geneva, Switzerland, is not known for its sunny weather, and seeing the comet here was almost impossible, though I caught some glimpses. I hope many of you have seen it clearly by now. It’s dim enough now that dark skies and binoculars are increasingly essential.

I came here (rather than the clear skies of, say, Morocco, where a comet would be an easier target) to give a talk at the CERN laboratory — the lab that hosts the Large Hadron Collider [LHC], where the particle known as the Higgs boson was discovered twelve years ago. This past week, members of the CMS experiment, one of the two general purpose experiments at the LHC, ran a small, intensive workshop with a lofty goal: to record vastly more information from the LHC’s collisions than anyone would have thought possible when the LHC first turned on fifteen years ago.

(more…)
Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON October 21, 2024

Back in April 2022, the CDF experiment, which operated at the long-ago-closed Tevatron particle collider. presented the world’s most precise measurement of the mass of the particle known as the “W boson“. Their result generated some excited commentary, because it disagreed by 0.1% with the prediction of the Standard Model of particle physics. Even though the mismatch was tiny, it was significant, because the CDF measurement was so exceptionally precise. Any disagreement of such high significance would imply that something has to give: either the Standard Model is missing something, or the CDF measurement is incorrect.

(more…)
Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON September 19, 2024

[Update: unfortunately, the link below was taken down before the tour, with no explanation. The tour was instead recorded at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=67mF5Yx7ZG0.]

Would anyone like a tour of the ATLAS and CMS experiments, the general purpose particle detectors at the Large Hadron Collider that were used to discover the particle known as the Higgs boson? A live, virtual tour is being given today (Tuesday June 11) on YouTube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=askq7-9CzrU, at 1700 CERN time — that’s 1600 London time, 11:00 New York time, 8:00 San Francisco time. Find out how these enormous, complex, magnificent devices are constructed, and learn how their various parts work together, 25 million times every second, to allow scientists to track the tiniest objects in the universe. Includes a Q&A at the end for participants.

Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON June 11, 2024

The 12th Large Hadron Collider Physics conference is taking place this week in Boston, and for the first time in a several years, I’ll be able to attend in person. I’ll post about it all week.

As part of the conference activities, I will be participating in a public event Thursday night at the Boston Public Library, a panel discussion entitled “Where the Universe and Humanity Collide.” The other panelists are Yale Professor Sarah Demers, a member of the ATLAS experiment at the Large Hadron Collider, and Dr. Katrina Miller, a particle physicis and a writer and essayist for the New York Times and other publications. We’ll be discussing the future of particle physics, talking about how we got into the field, and answering whatever questions the audience might have for us. If you’re in Boston, please consider attending!

Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON June 3, 2024

Although I’ve been slowly revising the Higgs FAQ 2.0, this seemed an appropriate time to bring the Higgs FAQ on this website fully into the 2020’s. You will find the Higgs FAQ 3.0 here; it explains the basics of the Higgs boson and Higgs field, along with some of the wider context.

For deeper explanations of the Higgs field:

  • if you are comfortable with math, you can find this series of pages useful (but you will probably to read this series first.)
  • if you would prefer to avoid the math, a full and accurate conceptual explanation of the Higgs field is given in my book.

Events: this week I am speaking Tuesday in Berkeley, CA; Wednesday in Seattle, WA (at Town Hall); and Thursday outside of Portland, OR (at the Powell’s bookstore in Cedar Hills). Click here for more details.

Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON April 15, 2024

Recently, the first completed search for what is nowadays known as SUEP — a Soft-Unclustered-Energy Pattern, in which large numbers of low-energy particles explode outward from one of the proton-proton collisions at the Large Hadron Collider [LHC] — was made public by physicists working at the CMS experiment. As a theoretical idea, SUEP has its origin in 2006-2008, but it was this paper from 2016 that finally brought the possibility to widespread attention. (However, the name they gave it was unfortunate. To replace it, the acronym “SUEP” was invented.)

How can SUEP arise? If a proton-proton collision produces currently-unknown types of particles that

  • do not interact with ordinary matter directly (i.e. they are immune to the electromagnetic, strong nuclear and weak nuclear forces),
  • but do interact with each other, via their own, ultra-powerful force,

they can cause that collision to turn to SUEP.

(more…)
Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON March 15, 2024

About a month ago, there was a lot of noise, discussion and controversy concerning CERN‘s proposal to build a giant new tunnel and put powerful new particle accelerators in it. This proposal is collectively called the Future Circular Collider (“FCC”). (The BBC reported on it here.)

Some scientists made arguments that FCC is a great idea, based on reasoning that I somewhat disagree with. Others said it would be a waste of money, based on reasoning that I again disagree with. But any decision on whether to actually fund the building of the FCC’s tunnel is still some years off, so I was reluctant to get involved in the debate, especially since my nuanced opinion seemed likely to be drowned out amid the polemics.

But I did eventually write something in response to a reporter’s questions, and looking back on it, I think it may be of interest to some readers. So here it is.

(more…)
Picture of POSTED BY Matt Strassler

POSTED BY Matt Strassler

ON March 8, 2024

Search

Buy The Book

Reading My Book?

Got a question? Ask it here.

Media Inquiries

For media inquiries, click here.